IIoT Edge Computing vs. Cloud Computing
As enterprise data sources becoming increasingly decentralized, the shortcomings of cloud-based architectures tend to rise to the surface.
What is Edge Computing?
In edge computing, critical data processing occurs at the data source rather than in a centralized cloud-based location. Other terms sometimes used to describe edge computing include ‘fog’ computing and grid computing.
The Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) relies on data from many sensors, controllers and attached servers, often across multiple, remote locations. Certain data processing tasks are best performed ‘at source’ rather than in the cloud.
Why cloud solutions (on their own) are not suitable for realtime IIoT data
With typical network cloud systems, data is pushed up to a server and then pulled back down by clients. This works well for videos, pictures, music, documents and non-critical applications, but is not a good design for realtime IIoT data. If data does not reside at the source, the data quality may be unreliable. Issues with the freshness, accuracy of data, and speed of delivery are potentially impacted when using a cloud architecture.
When supporting a complex IIoT solution, a centralised cloud architecture becomes costly in terms of bandwidth cost and computing resources. Latency and network availability issues also impact cloud based IIoT.
Comparing Edge and Cloud Network Architectures
- Basic data visualization
- Basic data analytics and short term data historian features
- Data caching, buffering and streaming
- Data pre-processing, cleansing, filtering and optimization
- Some data aggregation
- Device to Device communications/M2M
- Complex analytics
- Big Data mining
- Sources of business logic
- Machine learning rules
- Advanced visualizations
- Long term data storage/warehousing
Example – Edge Computing in the Field
Technicians working on a remote wind turbine use edge computing to view basic data and analytic information in the field. The essential data needed to diagnose the turbine is more efficiently delivered in the field without having to rely on patchy cellular communications with a cloud based solution.
Processing power is provided at the data source or ‘edge’ via standard PC hardware or other IIoT gateway devices. The centralized cloud platform is still utilized for more resource-intensive analytics, stored business logic and data warehousing.
The Business Case for Edge Computing
The business case for edge computing is driven by cost savings in computing power and bandwidth as well as its ability to provide faster and more accurate access to automation data at its source.
For many IIoT applications, edge computing is the reliable and cost-effective way to ensure data quality, freshness, accuracy and speed of delivery. Other factors such as the quantities of data transferred and bandwidth costs will determine the ultimate mix cloud and edge services.
Which network architecture is right for your business?
Edge computing and cloud computing are complementary architectures that come together to create powerful IIoT platforms. One does not replace the other.
The best IIoT solution for your business will likely be a mix of the two architectures. Deciding which computing tasks should happen in the cloud or at the edge requires careful analysis of your business needs. Software providers like Open Automation Software are ideally placed to provide the software infrastructure for creating a world-class IIoT solution as well as providing advice on how to best design your edge computing platform.
Download a free trial of OAS – start building an edge computing solution!
Complete this form and we’ll send you a download link to a fully functional trial version of Open Automation Software.